When an umpire makes an illegal call for a pitch being too low or too high, does he or she consider the bottom of the ball or the top of the ball in making the call?
Randall ... In reality, it's NEITHER ... Nobody's eye is that good, so unless your league has the MLB style ABS system we saw in play during the World Series, it's always going to be a SWAG (Scientific Wild-Assed Guess) call ...
A softball measures just 3.82 inches in diameter. Is anyone honestly suggesting an umpire should determine legal pitch height by comparing it to the width of a ball? Of course not. Umpires are expected to use judgment, not perform measurements with a softball.
one thing I tell umpires at my clinics is that every day your 6'to 12' limits will vary .. the important thing is being consistent thru out the game
(Hmmm! Let's try this reply again.) What do you say to your students B.J. when you see them not moving out to the mound area to get a better view of plays at any base?
Diesel.. I tell all umpires at my clinics movement is required and if you are tired/injured or just lazy we can use you as a score keeper up in the tower where you can sit and watch the game..
From your lips to the UIC's B.J..
Dave
SWAG is an excellent answer.
Benji