Does a runner going to second base have to slide or veer off on a double play attempt? Does the runner have the right to the base path to second base, thus, the fielder would have to avoid hitting the runner with the throw to first base by stepping out of the base path?
From the 2006-7 SSUSA rulebook: 1.45 • INTERFERENCE Interference is the act of an offensive player or team member that impedes or confuses a defensive player attempting to execute a play. A base runner must avoid a fielder making a play.
Kenny ... The base runner has the right to the base line until the potential interference circumstances quoted by ball_smasher may fit the facts ... We certainly don't advocate this base-running approach, but should the runner on his way to second end up with a new ball-stitch pattern on his forehead because of not veering off to the side or getting down, there is still very likely a potential interference call in play ... Be smart-stay safe-get out of the way ...
hitinrun5.. a base runner is entitled to his running lane as long as he doesn't raise up his arms or swing out his hip (like Reggie Jackson) or bump into the fielder.. if it is a close play at 2B then the runner should slide or veer off and not touch the bag to avoid a collision and should be called safe if in the umpires judgment he would have beaten the throw.. it is up to the fielder to throw over or around him and yes as stated above the runner must avoid a fielder making a play..
B.J.
You are wrong, the defensive player has every right to make the play,and he or she is not required to throw around or over the top of runner, as Dave said in the above reference, if runner happens to have stitch marks then so be it....and in this case runner would be out and double play called,,,,of course ar umpires discretion as always
magsdad.. yes you are correct that when the runner stays in his running lane that the defensive can throw straight to 1B and if he happens to hit the runner then I would have a live ball play on and no INT. on the runner .. again he has every right to be in his running lane
so what would you call if the runner veers to the right or left and the defensive player came across 2b and then attempts the throw and the runner who veered is now in his way?? would you call him out for INT ??
DD .. did give the ball-stitch pattern on the forehead of the runner reference but he did not say that he would have an INT. call
magsdad ... I didn't address any potential additional issues because it wasn't clear to me whether or not the OP had made it clear if the first put out of the double play attempt had occurred ... I agree with B.J.'s analysis and speculative conclusions ...
B.J., I would really never say that a runner has to slide only because of the legal issues that statement potentially carries with it. If a runner gets hurt with a slide, I would be potentially liable. I have seen lawsuits over more trivial things. So I will let them figure out how to get out of the way without that input. Yes, those stories that we tell after the games. It is definitely an odd world at times.
Nancy.. I never said a runner "HAS" to slide.. I stated above (if it is a "CLOSE PLAY" at 2b then the runner should slide "OR VEER OFF" and not touch the bag to avoid a collision) my reply gives them a choice because a runner on a close play going into the bag standing up has a very good chance of bumping into the infielder taking the throw which could bring an INT. call by the umpire and then if in the umpires judgment had the bump not happened a possible second out could be called on the B/R going to 1B ..
B.J., I definitely understood that. My comment about sliding was more for others because you know. No criticism to you, but even mentioning a slide can cause legal issues. The weirdest one dealt with was in a coed league. A girl runner got a high tag (she was trying to get low). The knot of his glove caught her earring and ripped it out. Of course as lawsuits go, they blamed everyone, the umpire, the park, the association, the glove manufacturer, etc initially. The only one that stuck was for the umpire since he did not make her remove her earrings.
For you umpires, how do you call this? I'm on first and a ground ball is hit. I run towards second where the play appears to have been made in front of me so I veer off to get out of the way. However, what I haven't seen is that the ball has been juggled or that for some reason I am not out as it appears. But by the time I realize that, I am tagged out or put out because I did the safe thing. Would you ever call a person safe at second in that situation. thanks for your input.
to reply or add to a discussion or post your own message and start a new discussion. If you don't have a message board account,
. It will only take a moment.